Toolpack: organizational development, surveys, and change

Employee surveys

Surveys are one of the most common tools of the trade, but many do not collect the information their writers intended; false expectations; are not used to generate action; or bias the results.

survey in computer

Some surveys are designed to collect information about a single, specific topic; others are more global in nature. There are satisfaction, benefits, and cultural surveys. Sometimes, they are called "assessments" or "instruments," but they are still surveys, and the goal is still actionable information.

Types of surveys

Whether they are given to employees, customers, or suppliers, surveys can be roughly divided into several types.

Tactical surveys

The tactical survey is designed to answer a specific question. for example:

For example, one company used a tactical survey to confirm that an ethic program was not needed; and found out that it was, indeed, important and provided a substantial competitive advantage. Thus, tactical surveys can shed light on key issues and confirm (or deny) assumptions, preventing fiascos.

The tactical survey should be very short and to the point, sent out and collected quickly.

Using tactical surveys to follow through on change efforts can help to find where change has and has not gone well, so that the change agents can learn from the best and help the rest.

Thanks to electronics, tactical surveys are easier, less expensive, and faster to conduct. They should become part and parcel of the decision-making and change management processes - if used with care.

Focused omnibus surveys ("strategic surveys")

Gathering information on a larger number of issues is the focused omnibus, or strategic, survey. This covers issues related to an organization's key goals and strategies, so it is considerably larger than a tactical survey, but it is still relatively focused. These surveys can be used as part of a strategic measurement system (e.g. balanced scorecard), or as a general diagnostic and motivation-for-change tool.

General omnibus surveys

Less common now are relatively unfocused omnibus surveys which cover a large number of topics. While these topics may be directly relevant to the organization, these surveys are generally "off the shelf" and only a few questions are customized. They can also be a good diagnostic tool, but are often too long to be time and cost effective. Respondents may also get careless on a longer survey, and make mistakes or rate many attributes the same way to finish without "wasting too much time."

Comparative surveys

While not technically a separate category, comparative surveys are often used in customer research to find the relative value of a product or service. In a comparative survey, the products and services (or working environment, or brand image, etc.) of different organizations are compared. This provides a greater perspective than simply asking about a single organization.

laptop surveys

Pulse surveys

Specifically designed to measure how well a change effort is going and provide advance warning of problems, pulse surveys are usually very short and have the same questions each time they are given. Pulse surveys are used to examine trends, and immediately catch changes so the organization can react quickly. They can be used with employees, customers, or suppliers, and generally are only given to samples to avoid "over-surveying."

Survey advantages

Surveys are relatively fast and cheap. A single survey can be used to obtain a great deal of information in a short span of time. Development takes much more time than administration, coding, and analysis, so once a survey is developed, it can easily and cheaply be used again.

They allow statistical analysis and quick, easy-to-understand reporting of relatively unambiguous results. They can be kept bias-free with greater ease than some other methods.

Survey disadvantages

Whereas a good interviewer can establish rapport and trust, surveys rely entirely on previously established trust and cultural norms. They may not be able to elicit honest responses, especially regarding sensitive issues. Respondents can fill out one part of the survey but not others, leading to questions of validity and bias.

Surveys cannot change themselves to explore interesting areas.

There are self-report biases (people may incorrectly report information about their feelings, attitudes, and actions for a variety of reasons). There are usually many people who do not respond, who may be different from the general population. Since a "good" response rate is about 50%, one must wonder what the "other half" really things.

Surveys cannot measure actual behavior, only the behavior people report.

Many surveys use inappropriate scales or questions, which allow too respondents too much room for interpretation.

Survey options - question types

Most surveys should include both open-ended and closed questions. Open-ended questions allow people to express themselves more completely, which is more satisfying, and also let them set the agenda more (especially general questions).

Closed-ended questions (e.g. "How satisfied are you? 1 = very dissatisfied to 5 = very satisfied) are easy to deal with statistically, take little time to complete, and take little time to enter into a computer. Therefore, there are usually quite a few of these.

Some questions ask people to check one or more relevant items (e.g., "What motivates you the most? 1. Money. 2. Benefits. 3. Satisfaction of a job well done. 4. Like to see chocolate bunnies coming out of the big shiny machine.")

Where possible...

Off-the-shelf?

Pre-manufactured surveys may or may not be useful for you. They can save development time and provide you with a "normed group" to compare your organization with (assuming various response biases are similar across organizations). However, they may also be expensive and the questions may not be completely usable.

Ask to see a dummy report before you order a survey if it comes with reporting. If you cannot understand the implications and next steps, ask about customized reports, or don't buy the reporting feature.

Customized surveys can include pre-manufactured surveys with optional items for your use, home-grown surveys, or surveys used by consultants and modified for your purposes.

They are often the best solution when resolving internal issues is more important than benchmarking and finding out how "normal" your organization is. To create your own survey, it is best to hire a consultant with experience in survey development first. Explore the issues with a small interview project and establish content areas before making up questions. The content should guide the nature of the survey.

The golden rule is to look at every question and ask, "What will I do with this information when I get it? How will I use it?". Then ask if the survey answers all of your questions and concerns. Few pass this test the first time around.

Toolpack Consulting survey services

Our survey practice is flexible and able to work on any or all parts of a project. We always design surveys that include the four key issues for effective action.

We can work with you to design and administer a survey which provides you with actionable information to be an effective tool for change.

More information on the survey process and our services.

Contact us for more information.

Copyright © 2001-2017, Toolpack Consulting, LLC. All rights reserved.